Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - benbovee

Pages: [1]
1
Uml Process / Re: Data Modeling UML Profile -- Two (2) questions
« on: September 14, 2016, 11:05:28 am »
Yes, I should have mentioned that in my post.  It was implicit, I did not make it explicitly clear; and thank you for doing so.

2
Uml Process / Data Modeling UML Profile -- Two (2) questions
« on: September 13, 2016, 05:33:35 am »
Hello, Folks:

I am one of the early adopters of, and published contributors to, the UML.  I only say that to establish your understanding of my knowledge level. 

Your article regarding the Subject is well written; and finding any writing on this topic is difficult.  It does address Generalization, Composition and Aggregation. 

Your article does not present guidance for transforming:
1. All possible options for a class hierarchy (think combinations and permutations),
2. Multiple-level hierarchies (i.e., generalizations nested in a generalization),
3. Simple associations--unqualified or qualified,
4. Link associations,
5. Ternary associations, or
6. N-ary associations. 
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
QUESTIONS:

1. Is your tool able to traverse a class hierarchy from a generalization not nested in another (i.e., base class), from top-to-bottom up on all branches, identifying all embedded generalizations, and bottom-to-top prompt users to select their transformation option for each generalization--ensuring this is done for all embedded generalizations at the same depth before iterating 'up' a level--until reach the base class?

2. Was the exclusion of transforming between temporal semantics of a Class-Class association (mandatory at any instant in time in existence for one instance) and an Entity-Relationship (may be for all time for all object instances) on purpose since it's ambiguous? 
Although this ambiguity is a pattern-observed fact, options should be provided to the modeler for EACH and EVERY relation--whether between Classes or Objects.

Pages: [1]